Skip to content
AFX Research logo

· AFX Research

Rail Trail Conversions and the Old Railroad Right of Way

Whether a corridor was granted in fee or as an easement decides what a conversion to a public trail does to the abutting land, and the deciding instrument is usually very old.

Table of Contents

Thousands of miles of abandoned railroad line have been converted to public trails, and the strips run past a great many ordinary parcels. If a trail borders the property you are buying, selling or lending on, the useful question is not what the trail is now. It is what the railroad was given in the first place, because that is what decides whether the corridor is somebody else’s land or a burden sitting on yours.

Fee or easement, and why it governs everything after

Three cards on why the original railroad grant decides what happens to a corridor, comparing a conveyance of full fee title against a grant of an easement for railroad purposes, with the highlighted card noting that the governing instrument is often a century old and hard to locate.

Railroads acquired their corridors in several ways, and the paperwork from the 1860s through the 1920s is not uniform. Some strips were conveyed in fee, meaning the railroad owned the ground outright and the neighbors kept no interest in it. Others were granted as an easement for railroad purposes, leaving the underlying land with the abutting owner, subject to the railroad’s right to use it.

Where the grant was an easement, ending the railroad use can end the right, and the strip is then simply part of the parcel it was carved from. Where the grant was a fee, nothing reverts to anybody. The two outcomes are very different and they are decided by a single old instrument, which may be a deed, a charter grant, a condemnation judgment or a federal land patent of the kind covered in rights reserved in an original land patent.

Locating that instrument is the real work. Our note on railroad right of way easements describes how those corridors read in the record generally.

What a conversion actually leaves at the recorder

Three cards on what a rail corridor conversion leaves behind in the county land records, covering the abandonment and railbanking paperwork, the deed or trail use agreement that is recorded locally, and highlighted, the federal proceedings that never reach the recorder at all.

A conversion usually involves a federal proceeding in which the line is formally discontinued and the corridor is preserved for possible future rail use while serving as a trail in the meantime. That proceeding happens in Washington, not at the county, and the agency file is where the operative dates live. Nobody is obliged to mirror it into the local index, and in many counties nobody does.

Locally you may find a deed or a quitclaim from the railroad to a public agency or a trail organization, easements reserved for crossings and utilities, and sometimes a recorded trail use agreement with maintenance and liability terms. Practice varies a great deal, and the honest description is that a corridor can change hands without a single new instrument appearing in the county index.

That gap is why searching the corridor and searching the abutting parcel are two different jobs, and why the term you order matters. A short search reads recent activity. Reaching the original grant is what the longer terms in our easement search packages are for.

What it means for the parcel next door

Three cards on what a converted rail trail means for an abutting parcel, covering the access and fencing questions an owner asks, the recorded documents that answer some of them, and highlighted, the reversionary and valuation questions that belong to counsel rather than to a records search.

Owners ask practical things. Where does my boundary actually run? May I cross to the other side? Who fences it, and who is responsible when somebody is hurt? Can a utility line cross the corridor to reach me?

Some of those are answered by recorded crossing rights, reservations and covenants, and those come back in a search with copies attached. The rest are not records questions. Whether a reversionary right exists, whether a claim for it is still open, and what any of it is worth are matters for counsel. A search is also not a survey, and rail corridors are one of the more common places where the line on the ground and the line in the description disagree, as encroachment or easement describes.

The takeaway

An easement search reports what was recorded and found in the indexes reviewed over the term searched, in the county where the property sits. Prescriptive crossings and informal use rights are frequently created without any recorded instrument, so a clean report is never proof a corridor is unburdened, and recording practice varies by county. Start the order online, or send us the address and the county and we will tell you which search term fits and what it would and would not cover before anything is ordered.

Order Your Easement Search Today

Certified abstractors search the county land records against your parcel and report the easements found of record, with a copy of every recorded instrument attached. Order online in minutes, or tell us about the parcel and we will help you pick the search term.

Questions? Call 877-848-5337 ext. 138 or send us a message